Fish Oil or Flaxseed Oil - which is best?

 

Roger's Introduction:

I have written in previous newsletters about the importance of omega-3 fats. While flaxseed oil is often recommended as a useful source of this nutrient, some researchers have favoured fish oils instead.    "Encyclopedia of Nutritional Supplements" is one of the main textbooks I use as I study towards a Diploma in Clinical Nutrition.   The author Michael T. Murray stresses that flaxseed oil can be beneficial for many conditions. However recently, in his own newsletters, he is now suggesting that "Pharmaceutical Grade" fish oils are the best source of omega-3 fats. The main reason for his apparent change of opinion is that modern processing methods are producing much higher quality oils than were previously available.

Below is one of M.T. Murray's recent articles in which he explains why he now favours fish oil.  He mentions a specific brand of fish oil which, I presume, is available in the U.S.   There are now fish oils of similar quality available in New Zealand.  Ask at a good natural pharmacy for their recommendation.

The Importance of Pharmaceutical Grade Marine Lipids

By Michael T. Murray, N.D.

Introduction

 

In the last year, several landmark studies have once again highlighted the importance of the longer chain omega-3 fatty acids such as eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexanoic acid (DHA) found in fish. The reason why these fatty substances are so important revolve around their role in cellular membranes. A diet that is deficient in omega-3 fatty acids, particularly EPA and DHA, results in altered cell membranes. Without a healthy membrane, cells lose their ability to hold water, vital nutrients, and electrolytes. They also lose their ability to communicate with other cells and be controlled by regulating hormones. They simply do not function properly. Cell membrane dysfunction is a critical factor in the development of virtually every chronic disease, especially cancer, diabetes, arthritis, and heart disease. Not surprisingly, long-chain omega-3 fatty acids have shown tremendous protective effects against all of these diseases.

Some conditions benefited more by long-chain omega-3 fatty acids than flaxseed oil:

Fish Oils vs. Flaxseed Oil

Although the body can convert alpha-linolenic acid, a short-chain omega-3 fatty acid, from flaxseed oil, it is much more efficient to get EPA and DHA from fish oils. Furthermore, there is evidence that many people, particularly many men, have a difficult time converting alpha-linolenic acid to EPA and DHA. Also, the long-chain omega-3 fatty acids, but not alpha-linolenic acid the chief component of, are also transformed into regulatory compounds known as prostaglandins. These compounds carry out many important tasks in the body. They regulate inflammation, pain, and swelling; they play a role in maintaining blood pressure; and they regulate heart, digestive, and kidney function. Prostaglandins also participate in the response to allergies, help control transmission of signals along the nerves, and help regulate the production of steroids and other hormones. Through their effects on prostaglandins and related compounds, long-chain omega-3 fatty acids can mediate many physiological processes making them useful in virtually every disease state as well.

My opinion on the superiority of longer-chain omega-3 fatty acids over alpha-linolenic acid is not new. I have always held that if manufacturers could solve some of the problems with commercial sources of EPA and DHA that I would wholeheartedly recommend them over flaxseed oil. The reason that I favored flaxseed oil over fish oils in some of my books (e.g., Encyclopedia of Natural Medicine) was because at the time the books were written there were MAJOR problems with fish oil supplements. These problems still persist in that most encapsulated fish oil products have been shown to contain very high levels of lipid peroxides, harmful contaminants, and heavy metals. Furthermore, because of the relatively low concentration of EPA and DHA in these products in order to produce therapeutic benefits people would have to consume 10 or more 1,000 mg capsules daily. Because of these factors, it simply made more sense to recommend flaxseed oil. However, a new development has changed my perspective a bit although I still think it makes great sense to utilize flaxseed oil on a daily basis as well.

New Developments

The ability to produce a highly concentrated form of long-chain omega-3 fatty acids that is free from lipid peroxides, heavy metals, environmental contaminants, and other harmful compounds. These "pharmaceutical grade" marine lipid concentrates are so superior to earlier fish oil products that they are literally revolutionizing nutritional medicine. RxOmega-3 Factors from Natural Factors is an example of this revolutionary new source of long-chain fatty acids. The key features of this product over regular fish oil products include:

Fish oil, mercury, and heart disease

Two highly publicized studies in 2002 demonstrated quite conclusively that fish consumption can reduce heart disease. The first article, published in the JAMA (Journal of the American Medical Association) showed that there was a clear relationship between dietary intake of fish and omega-3 fatty acids and the likelihood of developing coronary heart disease - the higher the omega-3 fatty acid intake, the lower the likelihood of coronary heart disease. This relationship was even stronger for coronary deaths. The second article, published in the New England Journal of Medicine, looked at omega-3 fatty acid levels in blood as opposed to diet. The investigators found a striking relationship between the blood level of omega-3 fatty acids present and the follow-up likelihood of dying from coronary heart disease.

The Latest Study

While fish oils may protect against heart disease, the latest study raises an important question - Is the benefit of eating fish counteracted by a higher intake of mercury? Mercury has been known to increase the risk of cardiovascular disease. Because fish intake is a major source of exposure to mercury, the mercury content of fish may counteract the beneficial effects of its n-3 fatty acids. Results from another study published in the New England Journal of Medicine show that while higher body levels of fish oils were associated with a decreased risk for heart attacks, the higher the body mercury level the greater risk of a heart attack, Researchers concluded that the high mercury content of fish may diminish the protective effect of fish intake against heart disease.

The Solution

Using a pharmaceutical grade fish oil supplement is the perfect solution to people wanting the health benefits of fish oils without the mercury and other contaminants found in fish. It is estimated that the use of fish oil supplements may reduce overall cardiovascular mortality by as much as 45%. This effect is not related to a change in blood cholesterol levels. The favorable effect is seen very rapidly, usually by three months into the study. In contrast, cholesterol-lowering drugs do not usually show benefit until after a year or more of therapy. As compared to drug therapy, omega-3 fatty acids provide remarkable benefits, are entirely safe, and are inexpensive.

My Recommendations

For general health, take 200 to 400 mg of EPA and 100 to 200 mg of DHA daily. It is best to take the supplements at the beginning of the meal. For therapeutic indications the dosage is to triple this dosage.

Key References:

Useful European and UK Links

Advice about Back Pain
Back pain is one of the leading causes of workplace absence in the UK. Almost 8 out of 10 people will suffer from back pain at some point in their lives.

fruit wholesaler London
Where does one find a fruit wholesaler in London? At Fruit for the Office we collect our fruit in the early morning from the famous Covent Garden Market.

Free Range Chicken
We sell naturally reared chicken, fed on corn to give it a deep satisfying flavour. Order here!

Oat Bars
Breakfast on the run? No problem! Our delicious oat bars will boost your day! Visit Quaker Oats for great products!

Free Newsletter
Stay motivated, eat well,
be healthy

 

Home » Articles » Fish Oil or Flaxseed Oil